Hello my dear friends,
I did have the best of intentions to post daily as I walked along the green line. Never mind … even if I had been able to connect to the internet, by the time we stumbled back to our rooms after each jam-packed day (and night) I could barely stay awake long enough to fall into bed. Then we were up each morning between 6 AM and 7 AM, back on the bus, to begin all over again. I’ll only be able to touch on the highlights at first because I suspect I will be processing these experiences for many weeks and months to come, but I think this is as it should be. I came to the Holy Land to see for myself, to take myself inside stories much more textured than the repetitious, sensational and calamitous sound bytes hammered into us daily by the media.
In fact, last night, just moments before I collapsed, it occurred to me that I’m much clearer on what I won’t be writing about than what I will. For example, I won’t be telling you that the security fence or apartheid wall (depending on your perspective) is an ugly and menacing symbol of diplomatic failure, that the Arabs despise it and Israelis defend it, that the separation barrier has indeed reduced the number of suicide bombings in Israel, but has left much of the Palestinian population (particularly in areas where the fence encroaches well inside the parameters of the original armistice agreement, or green line, with a sense of desperate hopelessness and I would guess in many cases suicidal thoughts. (One interesting “factoid” Gershon mentioned yesterday: according to Israeli military profiling of suicide bombers, over 90% of perpetrators suffered recent loss of a family member or close personal friend attributed to the occupation. They were unable to link these incidents to any other common metric. In other words, they are not religious fanatics seeking “martyrdom,” or from the poorest, most economically deprived refugee camps, or political zealots trying to “drive Jews to the sea.” Another myth, busted….) I will NOT be telling you that the most commonly heard claim on both sides is, “This is MY land, MY land, MY land.” After three days of listening and walking and more listening, I’m not prepared to declare a winner to this timeless debate. In fact at this point, I’m not sure it even matters. Antiquities link everyone in one way or another to bits of real estate all over the world. Particularly in this region, I have visited sites dating to so many struggling civilizations my head is spinning. (BTW, including Masada, which I have not had time to write about, although I will eventually….)
Indisputably, the fierceness of claims on both sides are directly proportionate to the intense desire to remain rooted to historically and spiritually significant land as well as to the perception and/or political reality that there is nowhere else to go. On the Jewish side, every draftee into the army takes an oath that “Masada will never fall again.” Each Palestinian will happily accompany visitors to terraces supporting generations of extended families and their olive groves dating back centuries. I won’t be telling you of the viral hostilities and suspicions deepening with every politically stupid decision and action taken by authorities on both sides, until today it has reached epidemic proportions far more deadly than swine flu and infecting every encounter and conversation in the Holy Land.
I see how very easy it is to find whatever you come here looking for … if you’re a conflict junkie, there is plenty here to fill news channels of every continent. If you seek to secure a Jewish homeland for all eternity this narrative is easily accessible. If you’re looking for the oppression of the Palestinian people under occupation, this is also simple to document. None of this is for me – I came here with the intention to find stories of promise, providing a different framework, a vocabulary of hope and new ways forward in order to slowly dig our collective way out of the noise and violence. Because I came with this intention, I am happy to report that the Walk the Green Line experience did not disappoint. In the posts that are to follow, I have chosen to set my sites beyond the narratives of one side or the other and instead focus on the stories of people of good will on all sides who are finding creative and innovative ways to live together under immensely challenging circumstances. Sorry, I’m out of time for now … but I will write more of the highlights as soon as time permits. I have missed you all and am anxious to see you on my return.
b’shalom,
Elissa